Tires are one of the most vital parts of your vehicle. They’re your only contact with the road, and yet, they’re also incredibly vulnerable to damage from potholes, nails, glass, and even vandalism. So it’s no surprise that a common question many drivers ask is: does insurance cover tires?
Whether you’re commuting to work or planning a road trip, understanding what’s covered under your auto insurance can save you hundreds—or even thousands—of dollars. This guide will walk you through everything you need to know, so you can stay confident and protected on the road.
Types of Car Insurance and How They Relate to Tire Coverage
Understanding the different types of car insurance is essential to knowing if your tires are covered. Each policy offers different types of protection, and not all include tire damage.
Collision Coverage
Collision coverage protects your vehicle when you’re involved in an accident, regardless of fault. If your tires are damaged in a crash, this coverage often helps pay for repair or replacement. For instance, if you hit a curb or a pothole and your tires blow out as a result, collision insurance may cover it—after your deductible is paid.
Comprehensive Insurance
Comprehensive insurance covers damage from non-collision-related events. Think of things like theft, vandalism, falling objects, and weather. If someone slashes your tires or a tree branch falls on your vehicle and ruins the wheels, comprehensive insurance may foot the bill.
Liability-Only Insurance
If you have a basic liability-only policy, your tires are likely not covered. Liability insurance is meant to cover damage you cause to other people or their property—not your own.
Roadside Assistance Add-Ons
Some policies offer roadside assistance that may include flat tire repair or even towing to a nearby shop. However, this doesn’t usually pay for a new tire—just the service of fixing or replacing it temporarily.
Situations When Insurance Does Cover Tire Damage
Damage in a Covered Collision
If you hit a pothole or get into a car accident and the impact destroys your tires, your collision coverage may help pay for replacement—especially if the incident causes damage to your suspension or rims as well.
Vandalism or Theft
Comprehensive insurance will typically cover you if someone slashes your tires or steals them. This includes criminal damage such as tire punctures or vandalizing a parked car.
Natural Disasters
If your car is caught in a storm and debris ruins your tires, or if they’re damaged during a wildfire, flood, or hurricane, your comprehensive coverage will likely apply.
Accidents with City Infrastructure
Some cities allow you to file claims if your tires are damaged by poorly maintained roads. Though it’s a longer process, it’s another avenue worth exploring, especially if you lack collision insurance.
Situations When Insurance Does Not Cover Tires
General Wear and Tear
Insurance doesn’t cover damage caused by normal wear and tear. Tread degradation, balding tires, or dry rot won’t be reimbursed—even with full coverage.
Lack of Maintenance
If your tires are over- or under-inflated or improperly rotated, and they blow out, it’s considered neglect. In this case, your insurance provider won’t pay.
Manufacturer Defects
If your tires have a factory defect, it’s the manufacturer—not your insurer—who should handle the issue. This is usually handled through a tire warranty.
Road Hazard Protection and Optional Tire Coverage
What Is Road Hazard Protection?
Road hazard protection is often sold by tire dealers or added to some auto policies. It covers things like nails, glass, or pothole damage that standard policies may not.
How It Differs from Insurance
Unlike car insurance, this plan only covers tire-specific damage. It’s ideal for peace of mind but doesn’t extend to other parts of your vehicle.
Where to Get It
You can buy this from tire retailers like Discount Tire, Costco, or even directly through some automakers when you purchase a new vehicle.
How to File a Claim for Tire Damage
Step-by-Step Guide
-
Take clear photos of the damage and the surroundings.
-
Note the time, date, and exact location.
-
Contact your insurer and ask if the incident is covered.
-
Submit all documentation and receipts (especially for new tires).
-
Wait for an adjuster to assess the situation.
Documentation You’ll Need
-
Incident report
-
Photos of the tire and vehicle
-
Repair receipts
-
Police report (if vandalism is involved)
What to Expect in Payout
Your insurance will only pay beyond your deductible. If the new tire costs $200 and your deductible is $500, it’s better to pay out of pocket.
Does Filing a Tire Claim Affect Your Insurance Premium?
Filing a claim for something minor like a flat tire may not be worth the risk. Every claim you file can influence your premium. Insurers may view frequent claims—even for small issues—as red flags.
Ask yourself: Is the cost of the new tire more than your deductible? If not, don’t file. Use your coverage wisely.
Tire Damage: Warranty vs Insurance vs Roadside Assistance
| Feature | Tire Warranty | Auto Insurance | Roadside Assistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Covers Wear & Tear | ✅ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Covers Road Hazards | ⚠️ (Sometimes) | ✅ (Collision only) | ⚠️ (Temporary fixes only) |
| Covers Vandalism | ❌ | ✅ (Comprehensive) | ❌ |
| Offers Replacement | ✅ | ✅ (Depending on event) | ❌ |
Tips to Protect Your Tires and Avoid Insurance Claims
Regular Maintenance
-
Rotate tires every 5,000 to 7,500 miles
-
Check air pressure monthly
-
Inspect tread depth
Drive Mindfully
-
Avoid potholes and debris
-
Don’t speed over speed bumps
-
Park in secure, well-lit areas
Upgrade Your Protection
Consider adding road hazard protection or choosing tires with better durability ratings to limit out-of-pocket costs later.
Know When to Replace
Old tires are dangerous. Don’t wait for a blowout to act. Replacing worn tires proactively is cheaper than filing claims.
Stay Educated
Always read your insurance policy. Don’t assume—ask your agent if your current plan includes tire damage or what add-ons are available.
Conclusion: What to Remember About Tire Insurance Coverage
Tire damage can strike at the worst moments—but being informed makes all the difference. The good news is that auto insurance may cover tires in many unexpected situations—from potholes to theft. However, routine wear and lack of maintenance won’t be covered. Understanding what kind of policy you have, what additional protection options exist, and how to file a proper claim empowers you to handle tire troubles with confidence and clarity.
If you’re wondering about other auto-related costs, you might also be curious: how much is an orthopedic visit without insurance? Or, in more complex cases like accidents, it’s crucial to understand whose insurance pays in a multi car accident.
FAQs About Does Insurance Cover Tires
Does car insurance cover flat tires caused by potholes?
Yes, but only if you have collision coverage. If you hit a pothole and your tire gets damaged, collision insurance may cover the replacement after your deductible is paid.
Is tire damage from road debris covered by insurance?
Only in specific scenarios. If the debris caused an accident or significant damage, collision coverage might apply. Comprehensive insurance may not cover it unless it involves a non-collision event like a tree falling.
What type of insurance covers slashed tires?
Comprehensive insurance covers slashed or vandalized tires. If someone intentionally damages your tires, you can file a police report and a claim under your comprehensive coverage.
Can you get reimbursed for tire replacement through insurance?
Yes, if the damage qualifies under your collision or comprehensive coverage. However, if it’s from wear and tear or poor maintenance, you won’t be reimbursed.
Should I file an insurance claim for tire damage or pay out of pocket?
If the cost is below or near your deductible, it’s better to pay out of pocket. Frequent claims can raise your premiums, so save them for significant damages.
